University of PittsbrughPitt Home | Contact Us | Finding People |
Department of Mathematics


Table of Contents


Summer 2001

HOME |

Symmetries of the Plane and Euclidean 3-Space: Report by Rolf Suabidessen, Paul Gartside and Bob Heath


Part 1: Symmetries of R3       Part 2: Symmetries of the Plane


Symmetries of Euclidean 3-space

Two subsets, A and B say, of the plane or R3 are said to be equivalently embedded if there is a topological symmetry (ie a homeomorphism), h say, of Rn with itself carrying one subset onto the other, h(A)=B. Thus A and B are identically `positioned' in Rn.

The first step in the project was to show that any two Cantor subsets of the plane are equivalently embedded (a `folklore' result). The second step was to explore the variety of inequivalent embedings of a Cantor set in R3. The last (incomplete) step was to link these so-called `wild' Cantor subsets of Euclidean 3-space with fully invariant sets of smooth 3-d dynamical systems.

The main result is that any metric profinite group is topologically isomorphic to the group of self-equivalences of a Cantor subset of R3. It follows that there are two groups of self-equivalences of Cantor subsets of 3-space which are algebraically isomorphic, and homeomorphic, but not topologically isomorphic. Thus the algebraic structure of the group of self-equivalences does not determine its topological structure. Results of Kallman and others show that this is strikingly different from the situation for groups of symmetries of manifolds.

Given a profinite group G, the aim is to find an embedding of a Cantor set, C, into R3, such that the group of self-equivalences of C is topologically isomorphic to G. In the special case of G finite, we use a rigid Cantor subset of 3-space due to Schilepsky, and the fact that every finite group is isomorphic to the group of color-preserving automorphisms of its Cayley graph.

To extend to general G, we construct relevant Cantor embeddings for all the finite homomorphic images of G, and carefully tie these together...

Preprint (in postscript): preprint 1



Symmetries of the Plane

A separable space X is countable dense homogeneous (CDH) if, for every pair A,B of countable dense subsets of X, there is a homeomorphism of X onto itself that maps A onto B. Thus, all countable dense subsets of X are `positioned' in X in the same way. The plane is (CDH).

A space X is strongly locally homogeneous (SLH) if X has a basis of open sets B such that, for any x and y in B, there is a homeomorphism h from X onto X with h(x) = y and h(p) = p for all p not in B. It had been shown that an SLH Polish (ie separable completely metrizable) space is CDH, but whether a metric CDH space is SLH remains unanswered (though a number of papers - by Anderson, Curtis, van Mill, Fitzpatrick, Zhou, Fletcher and McCoy among others - have appeared on the subject).

The intent of the project was to study the topological properties of the graphs of discontinuous real-valued additive functions (Cauchy spaces), especially discontinuous additive functions with connected graphs (Jones spaces), and especially the homogeneity properties of such functions. It is easily seen that every Jones function is not SLH, but it is unknown whether some Jones function is CDH (Heath and Saltsman recently showed that some Jones spaces are not CDH). Many papers and entire books (e.g., Kuczma, Kharazishvili) on Cauchy spaces have appeared but this and other questions remain unanswered.

The Results: The question of whether there exists a CDH Jones function was not answered, but a number of related results were obtained. It was determined that a Cauchy space is connected (hence a Jones space) if and only if it is not SLH. On the other hand the simplest Cauchy space (a graph of an additive function with only rational values) is not CDH. More generally if f is any real-valued function on R with a dense, meagre graph, then that graph is not CDH. Improving a consistency result by Fitzpatrick and Zhou, it was shown that a CDH Cauchy function must have the Baire property. Moreover a Jones space is Baire if and only if intersects every dense G-delta subset of the plane. Some results concerning the embeddings of Jones spaces in the plane were obtained.

Preprint (in postscript): preprint 2



MathZine Table of Contents



Mathematics Home| Pitt Home| Contact Us| Finding People| FTP Site| Top of Page